Accessibility View Close toolbar

30 Philadelphia Drive Suite A

Chico, CA 95973 US

530-342-6441

Open mobile navigation

Surgery on wrong-patients or wrong body part still frequent

The Chiropractic journal - April 2011

Surgery on wrong-patients or wrong body part still frequent

A study published in the Archives of Surgery (a JAMA publication) revealed that, despite warnings and safety regulations, surgeons frequently perform operations on the wrong body part or even the wrong patient.

A team of researchers headed by Philip F. Stahel, MD, PhD, director of the Dept. of Orthopedic Surgery at the Denver Health Medical Center, studied surgical cases dating from Jan 1, 2002, to June 1, 2008, reported by the Colorado Physician Insurance Co. Even out of this relatively small sample, there were a total of 25 wrong-patient and 107 wrong-site procedures.

Significant harm was inflicted in 5 wrong-patient procedures (20.0%) and 38 wrong-site procedures (35.5%). One patient died secondary to a wrong-site procedure (0.9%). The main root causes leading to wrong-patient procedures were errors in diagnosis (56.0%) and errors in communication (100%). Wrong-site occurrences were related to errors in judgment (85.0%) and the lack of performing a "time-out" (72.0%).

The problem occurs both in and outside the operating room. A quarter of wrong-patient cases reported in the study involved internists, and 32% of all the incorrect procedures involved nonsurgical specialists such as radiologists and dermatologists. The one death reported was due to a chest tube being placed on the incorrect side, causing acute respiratory failure.

The "time-out" is a three-step protocol instituted by the AMA Joint Commission in 2004 to prevent these types of mistakes. It required physicians and other health professionals to perform a pre-procedure verification process, mark the correct site for the procedure and conduct a "time-out" discussion as a final check before the procedure begins.

The protocol has been an obvious failure, particularly in light of the fact that the number of wrong-patient and wrong-site procedure reports actually increased since it went into effect.

The researchers appeared as surprised as everyone else. In its Nov. 1, 2010 report on the study, the AMAnews quoted Dr. Stahel as saying: "Everyone was under the assumption that when the so-called universal protocol was implemented in 2004, it would lead to a decrease in these 'never events.' Not only did they not decrease, they increased. In the first few years, the universal protocol did not prevent these never events from happening."

According to the same AMAnews report, written by Kevin B. O'Reilly, "the commission estimates that incorrect procedures happen about 40 times a week in the U.S."

______________

Sources: "Wrong-patient, wrong-site procedures persist despite safety protocol," by Kevin B. O'Reilly, Nov. 1, 2010. AMAnews.

Call Today!

Discover what chiropractic wellness can do for you! Sign-up using the form or call us at 530-342-6441 to learn more about us.

Office Hours

Our Regular Schedule

Monday:

8:30am - 12pm

2pm-6:00pm

Tuesday:

8:30am - 12pm

Closed

Wednesday:

8:30am - 12pm

2pm - 6:00pm

Thursday:

8:30am - 12pm

2pm - 6:00pm

Friday:

8:30am - 12pm

Closed

Saturday:

Closed

Closed

Sunday:

Closed

Closed

Location

Find us on the map

Testimonial

  • "I had terrible back problems for many, many years. I was going to the chiropractor 2 or 3 times a week. I changed to Masula Chiropractic and soon after he got his decompression machine. I went throught the series of decompression treatments and my back has NEVER been better! I just can't tell you how much better it is! It's unbelievable! It REALLY worked for me and hopefully it works for anybody else that tries it. Thank you Masula Chiropractic!"
    ~Lynn S.~

Featured Articles

Read about interesting topics

  • Back to School and Mental Wellness

    Summer is a subjectively fleeting season and school days are upon us once again. For children, this bittersweet time marks the completion of a period of relative freedom and the beginning of a new set of responsibilities. For adults, the onset of late summer and early fall signals yet another turn of ...

    Read More
  • Repetitive Motion Injuries

    A repetitive motion injury (or overuse injury) involves doing an action over and over again, as with a baseball pitcher throwing a baseball, a tennis player hitting a tennis ball, typing at a computer keyboard, and most notoriously, typing with your thumbs on the tiny keypad of your phone. It may be ...

    Read More
  • Left-Handers Day

    Left-Handers Day Left-Handers Day, celebrated on August 15th, was launched in 1992 by the Left-Handers Club, an organization based in the United Kingdom. Since then, Left-Handers Day has become a worldwide event and social media phenomenon. Around the world, approximately one in ten persons is left-handed. ...

    Read More
  • Peak Experiences

    Peak Experiences The American philosopher and naturalist Henry David Thoreau roamed far and wide over the hills and mountains of his native Massachusetts and neighboring New Hampshire. In his masterwork, "Walden," Thoreau famously stated that we must "reawaken and keep ourselves awake, not by mechanical ...

    Read More
  • Dynamic Warm-ups

    In a common occurrence, you bend over to pick up the pencil you inadvertently dropped on the floor. Or you bend over to pick up the soap bar that has slipped through your fingers in the shower. Or you bend over to lift a bag of groceries out of your automobile trunk. These are all daily events. But on ...

    Read More
  • Summer Sports

    Summer Sports In the summertime, everyone's thoughts turn to the outdoors. We want to get out in the sun and have some fun. Some people do exercise outdoors, such as running, walking, and biking, all year long regardless of the weather.1 For others, summer's warmer temperatures make activity outside ...

    Read More
  • Wellness Gardens

    Wellness Gardens When time is spent in an office or indoors day in and day out, some can lose that connection to the outside world. And that loss of connection can lead to higher stress levels and more health ailments without even realizing it. But when that the gap between office life and outdoor life ...

    Read More
  • Smart Shoulders

    Our shoulder joints have the greatest range of motion of any of the musculoskeletal joints in our bodies. The shoulder joint is really two joints, the glenohumeral joint between the arm bone (humerus) and the shoulder blade (scapula) and the acromioclavicular joint between the acromion (a bony projection off the scapula) and the collarbone (clavicle). The glenohumeral joint is a ball-and-socket joint and the acromioclavicular joint is a gliding joint. ...

    Read More
  • A Book and Its Cover

    A book cover may not necessarily tell the whole story and may not accurately portray the nature of the contents within. Publishing companies pay high salaries to their marketing staff to create cover copy that will entice prospective buyers to make a purchase. But many times the book itself does not ...

    Read More
  • When Your Spine Is In Line

    Good spinal alignment means good biomechanical health. Essentially, your spine is the biomechanical center of your body. Your legs are connected to your spine via two large and strong pelvic bones. Your arms are connected to your spine via your shoulder blades, ribs, and numerous strong muscles and ligaments. ...

    Read More

Newsletter Sign Up